New Client Alert highlights how AI prompts and conversation histories may impact litigation, evidence preservation and work-product protection

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (November 2026) – As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly integrated into business operations and everyday communications, a recent federal court ruling raises important questions about how AI-generated records may be used in litigation. RumbergerKirk Tallahassee partner Leonard J. Dietzen, III examines these emerging legal considerations in his latest Client Alert, “AI Conversations Are Becoming Discoverable Evidence: What a New Federal Court Ruling Means for Litigation and Preservation.”

The analysis examines the October 21, 2026, ruling in Fontainebleau Florida Hotel, LLC v. Botach, in which the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida permitted targeted discovery of a defendant’s AI interactions in a defamation case proceeding on damages.

The decision highlights how AI prompts, responses and conversation histories may constitute discoverable evidence when relevant to a party’s intent or potential liability, including punitive damages.

While the ruling does not establish that all AI communications are discoverable, it demonstrates how established legal principles governing relevance, proportionality and preservation can extend to emerging technologies.

Dietzen’s analysis identifies several important considerations for businesses and legal teams, including:

  • AI Communications as Evidence: Prompts and conversation histories may provide insight into the instructions, motivations and intended outcomes behind communications relevant to litigation.
  • Preservation Obligations: Litigation holds may need to address AI-generated records, uploaded documents, conversation histories and associated metadata.
  • Work-Product Protection: AI communications are not automatically protected simply because they relate to ongoing litigation. Protection requires an individualized legal assessment.
  • Third-Party AI Providers: Obtaining records from AI platforms may introduce additional challenges involving data retention, privacy, account control and production procedures.
  • Litigation Readiness: Businesses and legal professionals should evaluate whether existing information-governance and discovery practices adequately account for potentially relevant AI records.

The ruling underscores the growing importance of understanding how AI platforms retain information and how those records may become relevant during litigation.

For businesses adopting AI technologies, Dietzen’s analysis emphasizes the value of proactive information governance, appropriately tailored preservation practices and coordination among legal, compliance and technology professionals.

READ THE FULL INSIGHT: LINK

About Leonard Dietzen

Leonard J. Dietzen, III is a partner in RumbergerKirk’s Tallahassee office whose practice focuses on education law, collective bargaining, and labor and employment matters. He advises school boards and superintendents throughout Florida and serves as general counsel to the Florida School Boards Association and Florida Educational Negotiators.

LEARN MORE ABOUT LEONARD DIETZEN, III

About RumbergerKirk

RumbergerKirk provides litigation and counseling services in a wide range of civil practice areas including product liability, commercial litigation, construction, real estate, intellectual property litigation, securities litigation, labor and employment law, bankruptcy, insurance coverage, professional liability and administrative law. Offices are located in Orlando, Tampa, Miami, Tallahassee and Birmingham, Alabama. Visit www.rumberger.com.